In international perspectives on child abuse and childrens testimony. This study integrates social science research, social policy, and legal analysis related to children and the law. Children, social science, and the law, 2002 online. Until recently, children were generally viewed as unable to supply trustworthy testimony. Implications for child sexual abuse investigations. An impressive collection of chapters from internationally renowned contributors, topics include children s memory, interviewing children, issues. Interdisciplinary in nature, memory and testimony in the child witness should be in the professional toolkit of all psychologists, psychiatrists, social workers, and attorneys working with childrens testimony. Is there consensus about childrens memory and suggestibility. Child witnesses in court innocence lost frontline pbs. Top american libraries canadian libraries universal library community texts project gutenberg biodiversity heritage library childrens library. Although the ability to create memories seems to be present at least from birth, lasting autobiographical memories that a child can report of an experienced event are rare until approximately 3 years of age fivush, 1994, 1997. For over 25 years, she has directed mental health programs serving children and families in the public sector and taught normative child development in medicine, law, psychology, social work, and nursing. The final chapter focuses on policy issues, including psychological research to guide legal reform in accommodating child witnesses. Inaccuracies in childrens testimony memory, suggestibility.
Visit the apa books homepage to browse or search for other books. This paper argues that there are good reasons to limit or. Abstract this research paper investigates childrens testimony in judicial proceedings throughout the past few decades. The suggestibility of childrens recollections ebook. It has thus become increasingly frequent for courts to rule that because childrens heightened susceptibility to false memories is commonsense knowledge, expert scientific testimony is no longer needed to establish this fact in court, and juries can simply be instructed to consider it in weighing the credibility of childrens evidence. Leading psychologists in the field address issues relevant to the reliability of childrens testimony. Childrens testimony is often the only evidence of alleged abuse. In international perspectives on child abuse and children s testimony. Children s testimony of judicial proceedings throughout. Implications for sexual abuse investigations gail s. The testimony of small children has usually been considered truthful unless proved otherwise.
Although the historical literature on childrens suggestibility, with only two exceptions, led to jaundiced portrayal of childrens suggestibilityproneness, the most recent studies are more. Effects of interviewer support on childrens memory and. Thus, the importance of conducting forensic interviews that are free from bias and misleading information is immense, as these could lead to false reports. This book examines children s testimony from several perspectives and gives you insightful suggestions for increasing children s abilities to testify accurately about traumatic things that have. Visit the apa books homepage to browse or search for. During the past decade, the scientific study of children s memory, suggestibility, and eyewitness abilities has moved away from simply examining whether children can be led to err in their memory reports and has turned instead toward investigating how characteristics in children and their social environment affect the accuracy and completeness of their accounts. Legal authors dating back to the middle ages have voiced concerns. As a result, a child is interviewed by law enforcement and social. Furthermore, when parents or therapists read books with abuse themes to children, do children come to believe what happened in the book actually happened to them. Textbooks on developmental psychology regularly stress that the. We wanted the chapters to cover the exciting domains of both child and adult eyewitness testimony. As a result of an increasing awareness of child abuse over the last few decades, children have been admitted as court witnesses more frequently, yet there has been persistent wariness about the reliability of their testimony. Suggestibility is regarded as a major issue when children testify in court. Inaccuracies in childrens testimony haworth criminal.
Saywitz, phd, is a professor at the ucla, school of medicine, department of psychiatry and biobehavioral sciences. The next day, the teacher showed the children a torn book and a soiled teddy. One may fill in gaps in certain memories with false information given by another when recalling a scenario or moment. Thus, if the wee care children s testimony was a product of suggestive interviewing techniques, then their false allegations might persist long after the interviews had terminated. Child witnesses pose unique challenges to the legal system, and courtrooms are daunting and alien to children. In this part, we argue that, although psychological researchers disagree considerably over the degree to which the suggestibility of young children may lead to false allegations of sexual abuse, there is an overwhelming consensus that children are suggestible to a degree that, we. Formerly, studies in this area indicated that there were pronounced agerelated differences in suggestibility, with preschool children being particularly susceptible to misleading suggestions. But these are not studies of interviewerbias driven interviews in. Furthermore, in some extreme cases in which the childs allegation is essential.
Jan 01, 2002 children s testimony offers a comprehensive and uptodate assessment of issues relating to children s evidence. Part i of this article briefly describes the history and current state of research into children s suggestibility. This book examines children s testimony from several perspectives and gives you insightful suggestions for increasing children s abilities to testify accurately about traumatic things that have happened to them. Pdf the suggestibility of childrens memory researchgate. The fraud of psychiatric testimony and the rape of american justice. Adaptability has also been predicted to affect childrens suggestibility, because children who adapt well to interview contexts may feel more comfortable and thus be able to resist an interviewers suggestions more than less adaptable children. Memory, suggestibility, and eyewitness testimony in children and adults. Inaccuracies in childrens testimony combines the literature on obedience to authority with that on suggestibility to create a third literature. Hence, to date, childrens suggestibility apparently is not uniquely related to emotional intensity. Memory and suggestibility in the forensic interview taylor. Proper interviewing techniques must be utilized to safeguard childrens testimony from the effect of misinformation and suggestibility, as these could lead to false reports.
Childrens testimony offers a comprehensive and uptodate assessment of issues relating to childrens evidence. Inaccuracies in children s testimony combines the literature on obedience to authority with that on suggestibility to create a third literature. Childrens testimony wiley online books wiley online library. The suggestibility of childrens recollections ebook, 1991. Children s testimony is often the only evidence of alleged abuse.
Sage books international perspectives on child abuse and. Thus, the importance of conducting forensic interviews that are free from bias and misleading. The volume is an important resource for researchers, attorneys, judges, policy makers, legislators, and mental health, social service, and police professionals. Memory and suggestibility in the forensic interview by.
Suggestibility, social support, and memory for a novel. Mar 07, 20 inaccuracies in childrens testimony combines the literature on obedience to authority with that on suggestibility to create a third literature. During the past decade, the scientific study of childrens memory, suggestibility, and eyewitness abilities has moved away from simply examining whether children can be led to err in their memory reports and has turned instead toward investigating how characteristics in children and their social environment affect the accuracy and completeness of their accounts. It provides the most cuttingedge information available on topics such as child abuse, childrens eyewitness testimony, divorce and custody, juvenile crime, and childrens rights. Children, social science, and the law, 2002 online research. Are children more suggestible than adults, and if so, what are the implications for those who work with child witnesses. There is a trend among american courts toward admitting defense expert testimony on the suggestibility of children in sexual abuse cases. Suggestibility is the quality of being inclined to accept and act on the suggestions of others. Timely and truly international in scope, this volume focuses on the techniques and procedures used to accommodate child witnesses in legal systems in countries around the world and on the research investigating the effectiveness and implications of those techniques. Jun 16, 1997 inaccuracies in children s testimony combines the literature on obedience to authority with that on suggestibility to create a third literature. Issues in the empirical study of the sexual abuse of children john c.
Hence, to date, children s suggestibility apparently is not uniquely related to emotional intensity. It provides the most cuttingedge information available on topics such as child abuse, children s eyewitness testimony, divorce and custody, juvenile crime, and children s rights. International perspectives on child abuse and childrens. Memory and suggestibility in the forensic interview personality and. Studies reveal suggestibility of very young as witnesses. The credibility of childrens testimony is a hotly debated topic in americas courtrooms, universities, and professional organizations.
Pdf expert testimony on the suggestibility of children. American psychological association this volume includes contributions from psychologys leading authorities on the suggestibility of childrens recollection, a subject already known. These data suggest that the effects of suggestions may be extremely longlasting. Memories are the ultimate foundation of testimony in legal settings ranging from criminal trials to divorce mediations and custody hearings. Legal authors dating back to the middle ages have voiced concerns about childrens abilities as witnesses, citing their proneness to invention, their inability to distinguish fact from fantasy, and their incompetence for accurately recalling events uncontaminated by suggestion goodman, 1984. The credibility of children s testimony is a hotly debated topic in america s courtrooms, universities, and professional organizations. This book examines childrens testimony from several perspectives and gives you insightful suggestions for increasing childrens abilities to testify accurately about traumatic things that have. The children were interviewed 10 days and 10 wks later in 1 of 4 conditions. This book examines childrens testimony from several perspectives and gives you insightful suggestions for increasing childrens abilities to testify accurately about traumatic things that have happened to them. American psychological association this volume includes contributions from psychology s leading authorities on the suggestibility of children s recollection, a subject already known to be controversial because of issues related to the. Memory and suggestibility in the forensic interview. An increase in child abuse allegations in the 1980s resulted in mass allegations throughout the united states. Yet the last decade has seen mounting evidence of various ways in which the accuracy of memories can be distorted on. Implications for eyewitness testimony 19910104 paperback january 1, 1806 4.
Adaptability has also been predicted to affect children s suggestibility, because children who adapt well to interview contexts may feel more comfortable and thus be able to resist an interviewer s suggestions more than less adaptable children. Featured movies all video latest this just in prelinger archives democracy now. Sep 01, 2001 memories are the ultimate foundation of testimony in legal settings ranging from criminal trials to divorce mediations and custody hearings. The modern scientific study of childrens eyewitness memory was initially motivated, in important part, by the sensational preschool investigations and prosecutions of the 1980s and 1990s e. Most critical for child witnesses is memory development. Older children recalled more accurate information than younger children, and both groups recalled more accurate information after the short than the long delay. Some children hold onto their beliefs long after the suggestions have terminated. Part i of this article briefly describes the history and current state of research into childrens suggestibility.
106 461 1064 817 291 867 1540 1409 134 749 565 272 564 724 1583 1222 957 849 1572 1326 470 1090 610 645 320 170 707 1046 877 1280 1550 1160 635 223 428 1465 911 977 1229 14 1489 101 392 1428 110